Oily skin on the chin, nose, and T-zone is quite common. But what about your eyelids? Well, anyone with this skin type knows that eyelids can be just as oily as the rest of your face. And the makeup you wear on them can run as much as the foundation you use everywhere else. That’s why you need the best eyeliner for oily skin. These handy liners hold their lines better, with no smudging, no matter how oily your lids get. And they stay where you put them instead of leaving black or colored marks well above where you draw them. Long wear, smudge-proof, or waterproof, these products are a boon to the world of oily skin makeup. For the best tips on how to choose and use these handy additions to your beauty bag, keep reading!
Short On Time? Here Is The Bullet List:
- Drugstore Eyeliner for Oily Skin: L’Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Liquid Eyeliner
- Gel Eyeliner for Oily Skin: MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel Blacktrack
- Liquid Eyeliner for Oily Skin: Koji Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner
- Pencil Eyeliner for Oily Skin: CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eye Pencil
- No Smudge Eyeliner for Oily Skin: Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Eyeliner Trio
- Best Long-wear Eyeliner for Oily Skin: Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner
**Below are our more detailed reviews. Click the links above to see current prices or read customer reviews on Amazon.
The Different Types of Eyeliner
When you have oily eyelids, you can’t just go to the store and grab random eyeliners. There are rules you have to follow, the same as there are for your other types of makeup. You need to choose your liners carefully. Otherwise, you’ll be sporting the dreaded raccoon eyes a few hours after application. So, what is the difference between eyeliners, and which type is best for oily skin?
Gel eyeliners don’t look like other types of liners. They come in a pot, similar the kind used for face creams, only much smaller. These types of eyeliners are applied using a little brush. They can be used to create thicker lines for the cat-eye look. If you work fast, you can also smudge them a bit for a more subtle look that still gives you some definition. But you need to work fast. These liners dry fast. This makes them the top choice for those with oily skin since they set so quickly. Smearing is almost non-existent, even if you’re working up a sweat.
Solid Gel Eyeliner
These are similar to the gel pots but come in a much more convenient form. They are great for travel and quick applications on the go. But they have the same versatility as the gel pots. You can create that bold line for a more severe look. But it can also be smudged for a softer one, as long as you do it within 30 seconds of applying it. Once it is set, this eyeliner stays in place. The drawback is that the tip of this eyeliner can’t be blunted to give you the thick line you may be looking for. But you can layer it as needed. Plus it has intense, vibrant colors that last much longer than a Kohl pencil would.
Liquid eyeliners are one of the most popular choices when it comes to these products. It gives you smooth, stunning lines for that sultry look. These ones dry a bit slower than gel liners, but once they’re set, they shouldn’t go anywhere, even on oily skin. There are a few downsides to liquid liner, though. It isn’t as versatile as others since it doesn’t smudge for that smoky look favored by some people. You also need a steady hand to apply them, or you’ll be washing and redoing your liner to get the look you want.
These are also known as Kohl eyeliners, which have been around for years. They are popular for a few reasons. Pencils are easy to use and cheap to buy. They are also versatile. You can get thin lines with a sharp pencil, or leave it a bit dull and layer it on for a thicker strip across your lid. These eyeliners are also easy to smudge for that smoky look. For the best Kohl pencil, you need one that is solid enough for those steady lines. But it should also be soft enough to glide smoothly over your skin. Unfortunately, these can be trouble for those with oily skin. They don’t set like the gel or liquid liners, so could melt away or transfer higher up on your lids. But there is a way around this. Using some eye primer below the eyeliner and some powder on top may give you the long-lasting look you want.
Some people like to use their eyeshadow in place of a proper eyeliner. First, you need to dampen the bristles of a small, angled brush. Then dip in the eyeshadow powder of your choice and apply it to your lid-lines the same as with a normal eyeliner. This technique isn’t useful on the waterline but can give you a great effect around the edges of your eyes. For those with oily skin, this can also be the perfect addition to your other eyeliners. The powder can help absorb some of those oils that may cause your liner to run, holding it in place longer than usual.
Tips for Applying Eyeliner to Oily Lids
Liners that stay where you put them are extremely hard to find for those with oily eyelids. But you can get the smooth, perfect lines you want with a few simple actions. First, primer is your friend. Anyone with oily skin likely already uses this to keep their BB creams and foundations in place. The same goes for your eye makeup. Don’t just use any primer, though. Find one specifically designed for your eyes for the best results.
Check the package for a few key features to ensure your eyeliner will perform as needed. Long-wear, waterproof, water-resistant, or smudge-proof are best for oily skin. And if you can find a combination of all of them, it will likely be the best of the bunch. You should also carry blotting papers with you at all times. If your eyelids get a bit moist, just blot and go. With the right eyeliner, you shouldn’t even need to reapply.
Liners by Eye Color
You can choose any color you want for your eyeliner, but there are some shades that make each eye color pop. For instance, if you have blue eyes, a bronze eyeliner can give you a stunning look. The same goes for green eyes and purple liners. Brown eyes work best with darker blues. Of course, you don’t have to stick with just one color. You can pick a wide variety, from standard black to silver and gold.
Best Eyeliners for Oily Skin on the Market
Best Drugstore Eyeliner for Oily Skin: L’Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Liquid Eyeliner
This super slim eyeliner by L’Oreal gives you flawless lines that glide on smooth and dry in seconds. This felt-tip liner applies the right amount of liquid with every swipe in a continuous flow. This leaves clean, thin lines, but if you want to go thicker, you can layer it with ease. And because it is a liquid liner, it is skid-proof, drag-proof, and smudge-proof for a perfect line every time. The Infallible Never Fail liner also boasts long-lasting 12 hour wear every time you use it. You can choose either black, brown, or grey. The price is so low, you may even want to try them all.
- This liner comes in three colors
- The price is low, which works well for those on a budget
- The liner is easy to control
- It glides on smoothly
- It won’t irritate sensitive eyes
- The felt tip may dry up if not properly stored
- You need to apply it to clean eyes and let it dry fully to avoid smudging
Best Gel Eyeliner for Oily Skin: MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel Blacktrack
With the right brush, this gel liner gives you the clean lines of a liquid formula. But this MAC eyeliner has a much softer and silkier finish that is totally unique. It is easy to use for beginners as well as experts, though first-timers may need a few tries to get the perfect line. Once you have it down, you’ll have no trouble creating both thin and thick lines, depending on your style that day. This eyeliner won’t smudge on even the oiliest skin and is long wearing for those days that run a bit long. It is only available in Blacktrack, but this one will accent your shadow colors perfectly.
- It won’t smudge, even in humid weather
- You only need a little, so even a small pot lasts a long time
- It glides on smooth every time
- It stays on all day
- This liner dries fast
- The color is quite dark, so you only need one stroke
- This liner is pretty expensive
- It only comes in one color
Best Liquid Eyeliner for Oily Skin: Koji Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner
Koji Dolly Wink was created by Taubasa Masuwaka, Japan’s top model. It was designed to make every woman look like the pretty dolls of our youth. The fine tip gives you an easy application of the deep black ink for precision lines every time. You can keep it thin for a defined look, or layer it for a thicker, sultrier eye. This formula dries fast to get you out the door and onto your own personal runway even faster. It is also smudge-resistant, so sweat, tears, or excess sebum won’t smear it across your eye. Dolly Wink gives you hours of wear every time but washes away easily when your day is done.
- The price is decent for those on a budget
- It is versatile, giving you any thickness of line you want
- This liner doesn’t smear
- It lasts all day
- This liner only comes in one color
- The tip may fray over time
- Though labeled deep black, you may need a few layers to achieve a proper dark line
Best Pencil Eyeliner for Oily Skin: CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eye Pencil
Finding pencil eyeliners for oily skin may seem like an impossible task. But CoverGirl may have given this skin type new hope. This eye pencil is easy to apply, giving you the perfect line every time. It has a self-sharpening tip, so there is no need to fumble with a manual sharpener to get that perfect point. This eye pencil is also easy to blend for a smooth, perfect line every time. For a softer line, there is a smudger built into the end. There are four different colors, including espresso, chestnut, charcoal, and grey khaki. Use them alone, or create a unique look by using them together.
- This liner gives you a matte finish
- You can vary the thickness of the lines
- It comes in four colors
- It won’t cause irritation in sensitive eyes
- The price is budget-friendly
- It goes on smooth and even every time
- It won’t sharpen to a fine point
- Oily skin should still use primer and powder to keep it from transferring
Best No Smudge Eyeliner for Oily Skin: Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Eyeliner Trio
Oily skin needs an eyeliner that will stay in place no matter what. The Shimmer Strips Eyeliner Trio resists smudges for the perfect lines every time you use it. These eyeliners are also water-resistant, so it won’t run in damp weather or if you need to shed a few tears. The trio boasts 24 hours of wear, so you’ll look your best even if the party lasts all night long. Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips are hypoallergenic, paraben-free, and fragrance-free. It is also dermatologist approved and should be safe for even the most sensitive eyes. Each pack of Shimmer Strips has three shades inside. These include black, pewter, and champagne to create the perfect nude look.
- The price is low enough to fit into a budget
- There are three colors in the pack
- These eyeliners won’t irritate sensitive skin
- They come with a built-in sharpener
- It applies smoothly
- They are shimmery instead of matte, which some may not like
- Oily skin will still need to prime and powder for the best results
Best Long-wear Eyeliner for Oily Skin: Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner
As well as staying where they are, a great eyeliner needs to last all day with no fading. Otherwise, you’ll spend more time reapplying it than you will enjoying yourself. Milani‘s Infinite Liquid Eyeliner boasts long-lasting wear for up to 24 hours. It is also waterproof, smudge-proof, and smear-proof. This keeps it where it’s supposed to for every one of those hours. This eyeliner uses a super fine brush applicator that is easy to use to give you the perfect line. The color is intense, so you won’t have to add layer after layer just to know it’s there. To make it even more worthwhile, it has a great low price.
- The price is quite low, so is great for the budget-conscious
- It glides on smoothly
- It won’t fade or smear, even on wet or oily lids
- This eyeliner dries fast
- It only comes in Everlast (black)
- It may be hard to remove, even with makeup remover
- The consistency is a bit thick
- The brush may be difficult for beginners to use
Best Eyeliner for Oily Skin
Excess oil can cause runny makeup that needs constant reapplications. But if you choose the right products, you can have the perfect look you envy in your drier skinned friends. Eyeliners for oily skin are no exception, staying in place with no smearing or transfer. With these beauty products, you’ll never see raccoon eyes staring back at you in the mirror again. Every eyeliner we’ve chosen will work wonders on your oily eyelids. They stay in place, especially if you use primer for a good base before you apply them. But there is one that meets our criteria for the best eyeliner for oily skin. This is the MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel Blacktrack. Gel eyeliners hold strong, dry fast, and give you a great line that you can leave thin or build for a thicker, bolder one. This one does this easily, with a smooth application that only requires a little gel each time. It also dries fast to eliminate smudges. Though it isn’t technically waterproof, it still stays put even in damp weather.
Thank you for visiting Bloomgorgeous.com! If you like what you see in this article, please click on one of our Buy Now buttons to make your purchase on Amazon. As an Amazon affiliate, we make a small commission off any purchase made from a click through from this website, which is how we can provide you with these informative articles. You will not pay more on Amazon by clicking through our website because the price is the same as if you go to Amazon directly. Please take a look at our other buyers guides for all your beauty and wellness needs.